This site uses cookies to improve your experience and to provide services and advertising.
By continuing to browse, you agree to the use of cookies described in our Cookies Policy.
You may change your settings at any time but this may impact on the functionality of the site.
To learn more see our Cookies Policy.
THE REFERENDUM ON the 8th Amendment has thrown up some interesting battles in the public eye. Not least the split that seems quite apparent in Fianna Fáil. Things are more tense in that party than Kris Jenner whenever Kanye starts tweeting.
Let me start by seeing that I have no problem with people expressing their opinions on abortion. It is not an easy topic and morally it’s a quandary for a lot of people.
What I actually have a problem with is the make up of the photo. The photo contains 31 Fianna Fáil TDs and senators who are all opposed to repealing the 8th Amendment. Even though I don’t agree with their politics, that’s fair enough.
But just look at the strategic placing of the women in the photo. It smacks of ‘Oh they’re women. Stick them in the front’. I’m aware that it was a female TD Mary Butler who organised this photo call, that doesn’t make the placement any less jarring.
Irish women have been suffering from scandal after scandal in this country. It seems disingenuous that now a referendum about abortion is on the cards, women are now front and centre of Fianna Fáil.
Secondly, there is a certain hypocrisy when you see the green ribbon on some of the lapels. Mental health is something that’s constantly talked about in Ireland. We now have the highest rate of suicide among girls in Europe. In fact one of the only legal ways to procure an abortion is if you can prove you’re suicidal enough to pose an active threat to yourself. What a sad state of affairs we’re in.
If the people in the photos wearing those ribbons really wanted to improve mental health in Ireland then they would be advocating for more mental health support for pregnant people during and after they give birth.
Advertisement
Why would they though? It’s not like pregnant Irish women have the highest rate of depression in the OECD or anything like that.
The photo of the 31 Fianna Fáil TDs and Senators who gathered in Merrion Square Park to oppose the repeal of the #8thref. Am told it was prompted by the decision by FF TDs and Senators to hold a photo call for a Yes vote last week. pic.twitter.com/Gil5ProL7E
Thirdly, there is something about the amount of older men in this photo that scares me. I’ve been out canvassing for the past few weeks for the Yes side and you learn not to judge people. The amount of older men who I have canvassed who I have expected to vote no and are actually voting yes makes my heart soar. It’s actually made me ashamed of myself for prejudging them.
However, this photo reminds us that stereotypes exist for a reason. Men telling pregnant people what they can and can’t do with their bodies like we’re back in the Middle Ages. Last time I checked, nobody was making them to travel abroad to have a medical procedure done.
Know them. Remember their faces. Question them on this photograph and hold them to account. Fianna Fáil does not care about women. Don't make the mistakes of the past and don't vote for them at the next election. For shame. #RepealThe8th#Together4Yespic.twitter.com/Reg4N2iChG
21 Fianna Fáil TDs voted against having a referendum at all out of a total of 32 in case anyone had forgotten. Fianna Fáil hasn’t exactly provided us with a beacon of hope for the future.
There is a way to be pro life and yet not enforce your views on other people. Mary Black has demonstrated it along with countless others. You can be morally opposed to abortion and still be pro choice. It seems a number of these Fianna Fáil TDs and senators have missed that memo.
Mary Black is pro-life but voting yes for repeal after friends were forced to travel abroad with a fatal-foetal abnormality #together4yeshttps://t.co/zuUBZ8T4SO
This referendum is going to be close and if it does pass, it will not be thanks to Fianna Fáil with the exception perhaps of Micháel Martin.
Remember this photo call when this is all over. Remember the faces. They’re the faces of a past Ireland that we need to move on from. Repealing the 8th is the way to do that.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Close
8 Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic.
Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy
here
before taking part.
Friday 22 November, 2024
Friday 22 November, 2024
Download our app
'It seems disingenuous that now a referendum about abortion is on the cards, women are now front and centre of Fianna Fáil'
THE REFERENDUM ON the 8th Amendment has thrown up some interesting battles in the public eye. Not least the split that seems quite apparent in Fianna Fáil. Things are more tense in that party than Kris Jenner whenever Kanye starts tweeting.
Let me start by seeing that I have no problem with people expressing their opinions on abortion. It is not an easy topic and morally it’s a quandary for a lot of people.
What I actually have a problem with is the make up of the photo. The photo contains 31 Fianna Fáil TDs and senators who are all opposed to repealing the 8th Amendment. Even though I don’t agree with their politics, that’s fair enough.
But just look at the strategic placing of the women in the photo. It smacks of ‘Oh they’re women. Stick them in the front’. I’m aware that it was a female TD Mary Butler who organised this photo call, that doesn’t make the placement any less jarring.
Irish women have been suffering from scandal after scandal in this country. It seems disingenuous that now a referendum about abortion is on the cards, women are now front and centre of Fianna Fáil.
Secondly, there is a certain hypocrisy when you see the green ribbon on some of the lapels. Mental health is something that’s constantly talked about in Ireland. We now have the highest rate of suicide among girls in Europe. In fact one of the only legal ways to procure an abortion is if you can prove you’re suicidal enough to pose an active threat to yourself. What a sad state of affairs we’re in.
If the people in the photos wearing those ribbons really wanted to improve mental health in Ireland then they would be advocating for more mental health support for pregnant people during and after they give birth.
Why would they though? It’s not like pregnant Irish women have the highest rate of depression in the OECD or anything like that.
Thirdly, there is something about the amount of older men in this photo that scares me. I’ve been out canvassing for the past few weeks for the Yes side and you learn not to judge people. The amount of older men who I have canvassed who I have expected to vote no and are actually voting yes makes my heart soar. It’s actually made me ashamed of myself for prejudging them.
However, this photo reminds us that stereotypes exist for a reason. Men telling pregnant people what they can and can’t do with their bodies like we’re back in the Middle Ages. Last time I checked, nobody was making them to travel abroad to have a medical procedure done.
21 Fianna Fáil TDs voted against having a referendum at all out of a total of 32 in case anyone had forgotten. Fianna Fáil hasn’t exactly provided us with a beacon of hope for the future.
There is a way to be pro life and yet not enforce your views on other people. Mary Black has demonstrated it along with countless others. You can be morally opposed to abortion and still be pro choice. It seems a number of these Fianna Fáil TDs and senators have missed that memo.
This referendum is going to be close and if it does pass, it will not be thanks to Fianna Fáil with the exception perhaps of Micháel Martin.
Remember this photo call when this is all over. Remember the faces. They’re the faces of a past Ireland that we need to move on from. Repealing the 8th is the way to do that.
DailyEdge is on Instagram!
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
8th amendment Fianna Fáil together for yes